JW Mag Hotels

Best Hotels in Key West for an Unforgettable Stay

Brandon Fuller
1 year ago

Are you in a hurry?

Here is a quick list of hotels in Key West, selected based on their rating

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
The Inn On Fleming

8.9 / 10

(461 Reviews)

 From 347$
The Reach Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel

7.2 / 10

(338 Reviews)

 From 347$
Pier House Resort & Spa

8.1 / 10

(627 Reviews)

 From 471$
Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel

5.6 / 10

(332 Reviews)

 From 440$
Sunset Key Cottages

9.2 / 10

(108 Reviews)

 From 760$

Finding the ideal hotel that not only serves as a place to rest but also enhances your journey.

Choosing the right hotel in Key West can be the difference between a good vacation and an unforgettable escapade. With options ranging from luxurious resorts that offer every amenity imaginable to cozy, quaint inns that present a more intimate glimpse into island life, there’s a place for every taste and budget. Recommendations often highlight not only the quality of accommodations and service but also the proximity to Key West’s legendary attractions, such as Duval Street’s lively scene and the serene beauty of the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum.

Insights into the vibrant hotel scene in Key West reveal a commitment to providing guests with an unparalleled experience of comfort, convenience, and unique charm. Whether you’re drawn to the allure of beachside resorts that promise sunrise views over the Atlantic, or the allure of staying within walking distance to the Old Town’s historic landmarks, Key West’s hotels cater to the dreams of every traveler. Embarking on the search for the perfect hotel in Key West is the first step towards a remarkable journey through a destination where every moment is a treasure waiting to be discovered.

Oceanfront Escapes: The Best Beachside Hotels in Key West, FL

Table of contents

The Inn On Fleming The Reach Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel Historic Havens: Charming Heritage Hotels in Key West, FL Pier House Resort & Spa Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel Boutique Charms: Eclectic and Intimate Hotels in Key West, FL Sunset Key Cottages The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection

View all photos

8.9
Excellent
461 Reviews

The Inn On Fleming

⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 1016 Fleming Street

From 347$

The Artist House on Fleming is a cozy, colorful boutique hotel that embodies the creative spirit of Key West. Housed in a beautifully restored historic home, this hotel is known for its warm hospitality and charming, art-inspired décor. Each room and suite is uniquely decorated, offering guests a comfortable and intimate stay, complete with modern amenities and homely touches. The central location allows easy access to Key West’s attractions, while still providing a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle. The Artist House is ideal for travelers seeking an authentic and artistic lodging experience.
Check Availability

View all photos

7.2
Good
338 Reviews

The Reach Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 1435 Simonton Street

From 347$

With its stunning beachfront location and pristine private beach, The Reach Key West offers a luxury retreat that is both intimate and grand. As part of the Curio Collection by Hilton, this resort combines the allure of Key West’s natural beauty with the brand’s signature sophistication and service. Guests can enjoy a range of activities, from snorkeling and kayaking to simply lounging by the pool with a cocktail. The onsite restaurant, Four Marlins, provides a dining experience that captures the essence of coastal cuisine. The Reach’s elegant rooms and suites, many with sweeping ocean views, provide a serene sanctuary after a day of island exploration.
Check Availability

Historic Havens: Charming Heritage Hotels in Key West, FL

Key West is not only a beach lover's paradise but also a treasure trove of history and culture, reflected in its preserved architecture and historic sites. For those fascinated by stories of the past and the allure of bygone eras, staying in one of Key West’s heritage hotels offers a unique opportunity to connect with the island's rich history. These hotels, often housed in beautifully restored buildings, provide a glimpse into the lifestyle of a different age while ensuring the comfort and conveniences of modern hospitality. From intimate boutique hotels nestled in the heart of Old Town to grand estates surrounded by lush tropical gardens, each of these properties has a story to tell. Here, we delve into three hotels in Key West where history meets modern luxury in an unforgettable setting.

View all photos

8.1
Very good
627 Reviews

Pier House Resort & Spa

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 One Duval Street

From 471$

A true oasis of luxury and tranquility, Pier House Resort & Spa has stood as a landmark of elegance in Key West for over 50 years. Located at the edge of Old Town, it offers private white sand beaches, a full-service spa, and refined dining experiences, all within walking distance of Key West's main attractions. The rooms and suites are designed with comfort and luxury in mind, providing breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico or the resort’s lush gardens. Pier House combines the character of Key West with the serenity of a luxury resort, making it a favorite among discerning travelers seeking both relaxation and adventure.
Check Availability

View all photos

5.6
Good
332 Reviews

Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 1500 Reynolds Street

From 440$

Celebrating its rich history since the 1920s, Casa Marina Key West stands as a beacon of timeless elegance. This iconic resort, nestled on the largest private beach in Key West, merges the allure of old-world charm with contemporary luxury. Guests can indulge in oceanfront dining, unwind by the two sparkling pools, or explore the aquamarine waters with a variety of watersports available onsite. The rooms and suites are meticulously appointed, offering breathtaking views and a sense of serene exclusivity. Casa Marina is a testament to Key West's luxurious side, providing a sanctuary for those who appreciate the finer aspects of island living.
Check Availability

Boutique Charms: Eclectic and Intimate Hotels in Key West, FL

Away from the larger resorts, Key West harbors a variety of boutique hotels that offer personalized experiences, unique aesthetics, and intimate atmospheres. These smaller properties often reflect the eclectic nature of Key West itself, featuring distinctive designs, artful decor, and a level of personal service that makes each stay memorable. From historic renovations turned chic retreats to modern establishments celebrating art and culture, these boutique hotels provide a different kind of stay. They are perfect for travelers looking to immerse themselves in the local vibe and seek out the quirky charm that Key West is famous for. Let's explore three boutique hotels that represent the best of Key West's unique hospitality.

View all photos

9.2
Excellent
108 Reviews

Sunset Key Cottages

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 245 Front St

From 760$

Located on a secluded 27-acre island just off Key West offers an intimate and exclusive escape. This resort is accessible only by boat, adding an extra layer of privacy and serenity to your stay. The cottages are designed with a blend of beachside charm and luxury, each offering spacious accommodations, gourmet kitchens, and wrap-around porches with stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. Guests can indulge in the resort's private beach, dine at the acclaimed Latitudes restaurant, or relax at the spa. Sunset Key Cottages is an ideal choice for travelers seeking a unique and unforgettable stay in Key West, where the pace slows down, and the focus is on the sheer beauty of the surroundings.
Check Availability

View all photos

8.4
Very good
37 Reviews

The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection

⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
📍 417 Eaton Street

From 459$

Located on Eaton Street, The Saint Hotel offers a sanctuary of modern luxury and playful decadence in the very heart of Key West’s historic district. This hotel stands out for its bold blue façade and contemporary, artistic interior design, making it a haven for those who appreciate aesthetics and innovation. The hotel features a beautiful pool area, the onsite Tempt restaurant, and rooms appointed with all the comforts of a high-end boutique hotel.
Check Availability

Luxurious Living: Premier Resort Hotels in Key West, FL

For those seeking the pinnacle of luxury and service in their accommodations, Key West offers a selection of premier resort hotels that promise an unparalleled level of indulgence. These resorts are destinations in themselves, featuring expansive grounds with exquisite landscaping, multiple fine dining options, world-class spas, and attentive, personalized service. Guests can expect beautifully appointed rooms with stunning views, exclusive access to private beaches or pools, and an array of onsite activities and amenities designed to cater to every whim. Here we highlight three premier resorts where luxury meets the laid-back charm of Key West.

Location